Saved by My Chemical Romance

The incident between Frank and Gerard last night

Ok, I’m just going to go over how I feel about this and what I think I saw. There are a lot of stories going around and a lot of over-analyzing of videos. So I am going to over-analyze it as well.

First of all, I have a much clearer video than the one I posted before, I’ll put it at the end of this post. I have studied and studied all the footage I could and I agree with those that say something ”off” really happened. Here’s what I saw:

Frank jumped onto the box in front of Gee and looks like he wrapped his arms around him. Either Frank fell into him or Gee stepped away from him and since Frank had his arms around him it pulled Frank down and into him. They stumbled back… and here is what I see that I don’t see being discussed, Frank had let go of Gee BEFORE Gee pushed him… a lot of people are saying Gee pushed him to get him off. I don’t see that. Gee really hunkered down and pushed with his full weight. You can see Gee bend down to get leverage to push! Of course we then know Frank tumbled over pretty hard, sat looking confused and a bit like a scorned lover while Gee went over and kicked a light next to the box, went back past Frank without even looking at him and picked up the mic, went back and kicked the light again, and then Gee started over (what I think is angerly) towards Frank, Matt puts his hand out to stop him and Gee turns and goes the other way.

Ok, I don’t know what caused it and the cause isn’t what concerns me. Maybe Gee was just having a bad day… we may never know. I do want to say that to blame it on a girl (Lyn-Z) is wrong because Gee is an adult and responsible for his own actions. It was also clearly not from drugs or alcohol. Maybe it was nothing, but I finally get to see MCR in concert… even though I wasn’t really there… and there was no interaction between the two of them after that. No Frerard! It seems odd. I do hope they get it settled, whatever it was. I will feel much better once I see them smiling and back to their stage antics.

Ok, here is the video of The Sharpest Lives, it happens towards the end of the song. You tell me what you think you see…

August 23, 2007 - Posted by savedbymcr | video | , , , , , , | 80 Comments

80 Comments »

  1. thats good
    so is gee reekly dating lyn z?
    and rite b4 famous last words gee says this is 4 the 1 i luv
    so maybe he wuz apologizing 2 frankie? maybe hopefully

    Comment by Maggie | August 23, 2007 | Reply

  2. I think Famous Last Words was dedicated to Lyn-z (if that is in fact who is dating). I don’t know for sure. He made a comment also before Famous Last Words… something like “things have gone way too far tonight”, and I can’t decide whether that was aimed at Frankie or if he was talking about himself, or that it had nothing to do with any of it, LOL

    I’m so confused!

    Comment by savedbymcr | August 23, 2007 | Reply

  3. Oh no! I hope they made up.
    I think Frank was just trying to either create a frerard moment, or just screwing around.
    Gerard took it a bit over board.
    Poor Frank.

    It’ll be all good.

    Comment by Me | August 23, 2007 | Reply

  4. meh i think frankie was just trying to kiss gee

    but gee was an asshole :( and was all like “fuck off man im datin lyn-z”

    AND FRANKIE’S all like”I HATE U”

    Comment by IM THE BIGGEST MCR FAN HAHA | August 24, 2007 | Reply

  5. Maybe Gee got mad cause Frank stood on his box.

    Frank was like “on ur box, stealin ur fanz”

    and Gee was like “off mah box pleez, kthnx”

    Comment by savedbymcr | August 24, 2007 | Reply

  6. they had a fight why? I didn’t see it cause my mom has not let me on the computer. is franky ok?

    Comment by Jesse | August 24, 2007 | Reply

  7. Hi Jesse, I’ve missed you! I got a little worried when you didn’t return my e-mail. You are a little young to be spending a lot of time on the Internet… just be very careful on here, don’t give out any private info like your phone number or where you live, ok?

    As for Frank, he’s ok. I’m sure everything is fine between them and all of us fans have been worried over nothing! None of us really know exactly what happened. It may have just been an accident or maybe Gerard was just having a bad day or something. I know, your two favorite people in the world were pushing each other… but you do know they do a lot of crazy things on stage just for show, right?

    Ummm Jesse… you are in the same time zone as me and it’s just after midnight here… shouldn’t you be in bed? I love talking with you, I just don’t want you to get in trouble. :)

    Comment by savedbymcr | August 24, 2007 | Reply

  8. hrmm..

    i dunno what to make of that

    it does kinda worry me though :S

    im sure it’ll be okay between them though.

    it did look like an actual fight.. not just mucking around like usual..

    :S

    x

    Comment by gillian. | August 24, 2007 | Reply

  9. Oh, my.. Frankie certainly took a tumble, there. When was this concert?

    Comment by Mali | August 25, 2007 | Reply

  10. Oh, nevermind. I just noticed the date. *ditzmoment*

    Comment by Mali | August 25, 2007 | Reply

  11. Oh no. =[
    This is baaad. Very baaad. What happened?? [well obviously I know what happened I'm just saying about lke how their relationship has gone downhill.]

    Comment by Ashleigh | August 26, 2007 | Reply

  12. maybe frank fell into gerard by accident. gerard held on to frank to stop himself falling over because thats what everyone does naturally. he didn’t fall over and pushed frank back up to stop them both falling over. gerard put too much effort in to it and frank fell over. at the end gerard might not have been going over to frank but finding a water bottle or something
    : (1)

    Comment by rachel | August 26, 2007 | Reply

  13. i see what rachel’s saying.. but he looks reeeealy angry :S

    Comment by gillian. | August 26, 2007 | Reply

  14. jeepers
    i got franks msn and he was realy sad when i saw him on web cam
    him and Gee are not like the frerard any more
    cuz Gee is datin lynzzeeeeeeee (fuck i dont no her name)
    awwwwwwww
    im realy sad

    Comment by I LOVE GERARD WAY! | August 30, 2007 | Reply

  15. Uggh! I wish I had more information, it’s so hard just to try and guess like this. I hope they’re alright… Ugh, poor Frankie. For some reason, I’m really betting that this is Gee’s fault. :[

    Comment by @ | August 30, 2007 | Reply

  16. :S
    Wow i hope they make up
    :’( Poor Frankie!! And Gee :’(

    Comment by Ferard-4-Eva! (Soph) | August 31, 2007 | Reply

  17. i think they re just acting for the song!

    Comment by karla | August 31, 2007 | Reply

  18. i hope they know that stunt could break up the band

    Comment by bekah | September 1, 2007 | Reply

  19. i dunno, i couldnt see too much, but i think i agree with your version on this site…. oh well im sure theyre over it by now!! =)
    (ever the optimist!!…i probably didnt spell that right… lol)

    Comment by sophie | September 1, 2007 | Reply

  20. omg i hope they r ok i think gerard might started drinkin again

    Comment by emily | September 2, 2007 | Reply

  21. gee isn’t drinking again.

    and they’re okay again XD there’s more recent videos up, and they’re back to normal XD

    Comment by gillian. | September 2, 2007 | Reply

  22. i dont think theres been any frerard since then, there was none on the 29th show,
    and gerard looks like he’s gonna explode after he pushes frank away
    are they back tho?

    Comment by Julia | September 2, 2007 | Reply

  23. what gerard is engeged to elixa cuts whats this lynze crap?

    Comment by MCR fan | September 3, 2007 | Reply

  24. oops i meant eliza

    Comment by MCR fan | September 3, 2007 | Reply

  25. The engagement to Eliza has been off for awhile. He is now with Lyn-z from MSI apparently.

    Comment by savedbymcr | September 4, 2007 | Reply

  26. OMG! Argh! NOOOOOO! Make Up! NOW! I think they were both as bad as each other cause Frank doesn’t really Let go when Gee tries to get him off, But Gee did go a bit mental, Maybe just a bit touchy that day, Ahhhh I hope They Make Up! I’m seeing them in November No Hating I wanna Feel the Love Guys! =] Tee Hee =]

    Comment by Hannah | September 4, 2007 | Reply

  27. aww! frankie was just playing around and then when frank walked off gerard threw somthing at him! i hope frank isent hurt! and i hope they made up

    Comment by MCR fan | September 6, 2007 | Reply

  28. THAT WAS A STAGED FIGHT! IT WAS NOT REAL! FRANKIE AND GERARD ARE FINE!

    Comment by Jess | September 8, 2007 | Reply

  29. I don’t think it was staged, cuz when they’re shoving each other after Frank ‘falls’ on him, Ray looks over for a split second. Plus it does look like Gerard threw something at him after the song ended. That was defintley an angry stomp to the other side of the stage…

    Comment by Innen | September 8, 2007 | Reply

  30. Yeah that wasn’t a staged fight!That was a real one!
    I can’t believe that Gerard went that far!I have a really bad feeling about this!I hope that they don’t break up or kick someone out cuz that would just be the worst to see an amazing band like MCR break up!I can tell you that I am not very happy after I saw that video cuz it almost brought me to tears to see them fighting like that!

    Comment by Carolina | September 9, 2007 | Reply

  31. fuck man, that looked vicious and by the way yes. gerard is married to Lyn-z and i’m not kidding!

    Comment by loz | September 14, 2007 | Reply

  32. omg everyone should just forget about it, like jeeze , i dont think gee meant to hurt him at all, and if you guys all love frank why do you have to go and diss gee when gee is like his bestfriend, wouldnt that hurt franks feelings if he knew most his fans hate his bestfriend…? think it over

    Comment by Tatyana | September 21, 2007 | Reply

  33. I cant believe that…awwwwwww poor frankiiee =(
    But i remember in a recent interview that gerard said he had to “think this band over” and they made it sound like their next album would be t heir last….could it be related somehow?
    Just an idea.

    Comment by HellKat | September 23, 2007 | Reply

  34. omg!! wow i jope they make up, and ya Gee Looked like he was Really Mad…… I hope there all Right Thugh……….

    Comment by MizzEmo | September 23, 2007 | Reply

  35. OMG That Definately Weren’t Staged, And It Did Look Like Frank Was All Like “Dude, I’m Just Giving You A Hug!”, But No Offence As Much As I Think Gerard Way Is Awesome, That Was A Pretty Low Thing To Do Like Ignore His Mate Afterf He Clearly Hurt His Feelings And Him Physically.

    But I’m Sure They’ve Patched It Up Or They Will, Their Bestest Buddies And Trust Me When I Say This When Your Best Mates With Someone Then You NEVER Stay Angry With Them Forever, They May Not Ever Be Best Friends Again But, I’m Sure They’ll Be Best Friends By The End Of The Week

    Comment by Stacey | September 28, 2007 | Reply

  36. No, you have it all wrong. Gerard dedicated that to Lyn-Z, Bahar, Dawn, Frank, Brian, all of MCR, and me.

    Comment by M | October 1, 2007 | Reply

  37. what happened to Gerard. He has become a gerk since he has been married tolyn-z.

    Comment by Goth girl | October 6, 2007 | Reply

  38. I seriously hope everything is alright between those two. I think in someways, Gerard’s not doing anything “sexual” with Frank is because Lyn-Z doesn’t want everyone to know that Gerard is messing around with one of his band mates, who’s a guy. I’m just saying this, but I don’t think she wants to admit that she married a bi guy who also likes Frank. Just saying, don’t kill me.

    Comment by katie | October 15, 2007 | Reply

  39. yeah gerard is drinking again unless its every once in a while…the other night at the show i went to he was drinking a beer onstage…and he was slurring…we werent allowed to take pics or videos otherwise i would have…

    Comment by lex | October 27, 2007 | Reply

  40. OO

    Firstly, I heard somewhere that Gerard dedicated “Famous Last Words” to Mikey. This was because Mikey was SUPPOSEDLY going to leave the band due to his mental illness or something, so Gerard was dedicating it to him. The lyrics fit, no? ^^

    Woah. Gerard was practically hurling Frank away and pushing him to the floor. I don’t think he was drunk though, maybe just agitated, ’specially when he kicked the lights. But he seemed… sorta fine after that. >.> Song was great tho xD

    Comment by MyChem | October 30, 2007 | Reply

  41. gerard is NOT drinking again.

    geez.

    any mcr fan should no he’d NEVER go back to that..

    Comment by gillian. | December 9, 2007 | Reply

  42. that wasn’t aggresive at all!!
    WTF??? that was not he didn’t push him off in a aggrevated way wth!

    Comment by athena | December 21, 2007 | Reply

  43. and famous last words is about when the pationt dies next to a lover DUHHHHH!HHHH he was with k still when he was writting then they broke up

    Comment by athena | December 21, 2007 | Reply

  44. I am going to say this to everyone…

    Any comments left that are negative towards other people or seem to be instigating a verbal arguement will be deleted. This is a place to discuss MCR *RESPECTFULLY*. This event happened a long time ago, and we could all probably argue all day over what we saw and what we thing may or may not have caused it. I personally saw it as aggression, but the boys seemed to have worked it out. This is merely my opinion, what I saw. Everyone is free to have their opinions and do not deserve to be lashed out at.

    To post on this site you must be respectful to the other fans. I have allowed several comments in various places on this site that were questionable (in my opinion), but I will not let it get out of control. This will NOT turn into a place to argue or bash other people. It is derespectful to the other fans, but most of all to My Chemical Romance. They deserve better than that. So if nothing else, control yourself and be a positive representitive of My Chem for their sake.

    Thanks guys for keeping things on here positive and discussing things in a mature way. I just want this to be a positive place for fans and non-fans to find out more about the POSITIVE effects of MCR.

    Comment by savedbymcr | December 21, 2007 | Reply

  45. okay now i know the concert was forever ago but people are still talking about it so i will put my input. i was at the concert, now i was in the last row of the covered part but i still saw everything and i have watched the video over and OVER again and i think that they all need a break from the rode, those boys have been working for 5 years stright and i am glad they are finally going to get the breat they need.

    Now i am not saying break up, far from that, i am a huge fane i have seen them 8 times (once out of state in Jersey for bamboozle) but i mean come on the last month of the concerts they just finished had all of 3 or 2 of all five, bob got hurt, frank and family problems and mikey…well no one knows whats going on with that boy but it was ony ray and gerard and not that i am saying anything bad about the boys but they really do need a break, or they are going to end up breaking up or killing eachother and none of us want that.

    -alexx

    Comment by Alexx | December 26, 2007 | Reply

  46. and no i really dont think gerard is back on drug, or drinking, he is around to many people that love him, i mean he may have thought about it, i used to be an addict (no where near his extream) and i know i still think about using again, its in out nature but i dont think he is, and that fight…i dont know i am still ut on that, gerard really seemed angry, and for most of you, you didnt even see the whole thing because the camera cuts away but, he really pushed him and frank was really suprised by that, i mean when he went down he stayed down for a few minutes out of shock and they reast of the show he didnt go by gerard at all, but like i said before, they need a break or they are going to kill eachother.

    -alexx

    Comment by Alexx | December 26, 2007 | Reply

  47. I seriously hope things are ok between Gee and Frank…

    Awwwwwww…poor Frankie :(

    Comment by Luving.Orlando.And.MCR.Forever! | January 6, 2008 | Reply

  48. ok i know this was posted a while ago but i gotta say this

    1) IDK what that little fight was about but i think its over now

    2) i read some comments referring to gerard drinking again which HE IS NOT DOING. NO. NEVER. NOT. HE REFUSES. PLEASE DONT BELIEVE ANYONE WHO SAYS HE IS. HE WOULDN’T. HE PROMISED HIMSELF, AND US.

    3) I didnt rly mind that lynz chick until she started causing the band to have outbreaks like this…. now i dont much care for her.

    Comment by Autumn | March 25, 2008 | Reply

  49. “Outbreak” is probably not the correct word to use. Blaming Gerard’s wife for it doesn’t make sense either. I doubt the “fight” was serious. They were just joking around. They weren’t even close to “killing each other” in fact, Projekt Revolution was probably the best tour they have ever been on. Gerard isn’t drinking or doing drugs and if anyone says he is and/or claims it has something to do with Lyn-Z, they are full of shit. The guys were happier than ever on that tour. If you can’t recognize that, then do you know them as well as you think? Also, Gerard didn’t kiss Frank because he “liiiiikes” him. He’s not bisexual. He wanted to piss off homophobes. Simple as that. They’re fine.

    Comment by Kat | April 8, 2008 | Reply

  50. From what I understand about the incident, recording to a video you can watch on youtube which has a link to a message that was posted anonymously on an mcr site, Lyn-Z told Gerard she didn’t think he should be kissing Frank anymore, since the two of them were together.
    Keep in mind that I have nothing against Lyn-Z. MSI is one of my fav. bands and I find it rediculas that people “hate her” just because that’s who Gerard decided to marry.
    But from what I understand: Frank was being Frank and doing his usual routine of jumping all over Gerard and trying to kiss him, Gerard didn’t like it and tried to move away. Frank held on to keep his balance before letting go, and Gerard (who had told Frank previously that he wasn’t going to do that anymore) got angry and pushed him.
    There are rumors circulating that Frank doesn’t like Lyn-Z at all, and that Bob also isn’t fond of her, but those are just rumors. No one really knows if there is any truth to those.
    However MSI has been quoted calling MCR “nazi’s” not to mention Lyn-Z said she hated MCR music.
    There is also a picture going around (i don’t know if any of you have seen it) of what appears to be Lyn-Z pushing Frank away from Gerard.
    I can agree with Kat by saying that there was never a “Frerard” they are/were? just good friends who like the shock effect they could get out of people.
    Everyone is saying that he has changed dramatically.
    Some are blaming Lyn-Z saying she has him back on drugs and alcohol.
    He’s lost a lot of weight recently (i thought marriage was supposed to fatten you up?) and i’ve also heard a rumor that he threw vomit at fans.
    I’m doubt he would do any of those things, but you never know.
    The truth is: none of us will really ever know what caused the fight, why he’s changing so much, or what this is all about unless one of them speaks out.
    I’m perfectly fine with Gerard being married and I wish him all the happiness in the world but I do have my concerns.
    He moved on from Eliza (who was reported to be using him) very quickly, which isn’t exactly healthy. And now he’s promoting the violent behaviour that MCR has always been against.
    If he’s happy, then that’s great. It’s really none of any of our business what he does with his life, but I know we’re all just concerned for our Gee. :]
    Hopefully things will settle down soon.

    Comment by Rae | April 16, 2008 | Reply

  51. Rae, where do i find the pic where lyn-z pushes frank?o_O I so want to see that!

    Comment by Mia | May 13, 2008 | Reply

  52. It honestly looks staged and judging by the fact that Ray looked toward them and (though it was really hard to tell and i might be wrong) smiled, I think they are okay… and, i was reading a comment and I really think it’s strange that MSI would call MCR nazi’s… can anyone bring up the article(s) where they say that?

    Comment by Kami | May 14, 2008 | Reply

  53. I think Gerard was actually angry. Kami, if Ray smiled, it may have been because he thought that they were only fooling around. He only looked over for a second, so he didn’t see how angry Gerard seemed.
    There are a number of reasons for Gerard acting the way he did. If what I’m hearing about Lyn-Z is true, that could have been it. And yeah, maybe he was having a bad day, or he was stressed, or maybe even he’d been having problems with Frank and so on. I don’t know if Gerard would take it out on Frank if he had a bad day, but you never know.
    I saw basicly what you saw, and you pointed out some things I never noticed before. I’m not sure if I noticed somebody stopping Gerard as he walked (rather quickly and angrily) towards Frank. What worries me about that is he really did look very angry at Frank, almost like he wanted to hurt him, which is very unlike Gerard.
    I’m sure it’s over and taken care of by now. This was nearly a year ago. As for future fights, however, I’m not sure what’s going to happen. I don’t know if Gerard is changing as drasticly as people are saying, either. But I do know that people change, and this can cause conflict. We’ll have to stay tuned to see what happens.

    Comment by Allie | May 18, 2008 | Reply

  54. i know this is way old and all but since people are discussing it i thought i’s give my two cents.
    yes, gerard looks terribly angry and out of character in this video and yes he pushed frank rather roughly but keep in mind that it was probably really fucking hot out and i doubt anyone wants someone on top of them…but again thats a silly reason to be violent.
    like all friends im sure frank and gerard fight every so often and who knows maybe it had something to do with lynz maybe not.
    but as of recently gerard and frank have been fine,sure theres no frerard stuff anymore but they seem to be on really good terms like before.
    in like novemeber frank had a “i ♥ gerard” shirt.
    so im sure they’re fine….now.

    and as for gerard changing everyone notices it.
    but like everyone else hes just a person,he has the right to change.
    i never heard a legit story about him being an ass to fans,there are certain people online who claim to like MCR,claim to have met them and maybe even claim gerard was an asshole to them,you shouldnt really believe what you hear online or whatever.
    and i highly highly doubt our boy is back on drugs.
    people saying lynz got him back into that shit need to shove it.
    he wouldnt let anyone get him back into that after what he went through.
    in an interview he stated “i barely take nyquil when im sick cause i remember everything that happened” referring to drug use..hes way smarter than to do that.
    and as far as him not seeming to be his usual self actually there are a couple videos on youtube from FUSE where they interview mikey and gerard before their MSG show and one where they interview frank,mikey and gerard…and he seemed amazingly happy.
    like he was glowing.
    i think what him and all the guys need is time off to live and be with their families, especially since 3/5 of them are married.
    im sure when they come back they’ll be happier,tighter and better than ever.
    as for gerard’s weight loss…hes been skinny for a while now i doubt its drugs.
    and at the MSG show he looked as if he put on a couple healthy pounds.

    it may seem like i have no life lol but im just trying to state what i believe is the truth.
    our boys will be fine,sleep soundly.

    Comment by cynyster | June 1, 2008 | Reply

  55. gerard looks like he has changed really. some of my friends say he look stuck-up but i hoped he is not.
    well, he looks more confident than the period of the second album.
    i see him smiling less during live shows or interviews .. he looks more serious than when he was drunk (of course, and we are all happy that he is sober but i was wondering will his character take a turn for the worse?)

    or perhaps he just turned 30 and grew more mature. yes. that should be it. and since he is married to a girl maybe he decided to cut the fooling-sexually-around with a guy.

    sure hope that MCR will never become one of the sell-outs.

    Comment by Jenny | June 2, 2008 | Reply

  56. btw cynyster, however hard to admit, it is hard to say that gerard will stay true to his word that he will never touch drugs and alcohol. of couse, we do hope that is so and we prefer to believe it, but love is a powerful thing. who knows, he might be really influenced by his love for lyn-z :(

    HOPE NOT!

    just saying that it might happen, so we can prepare ourselves for the worst.

    Comment by Jenny | June 2, 2008 | Reply

  57. …..I think this was staged, or at least somewhat planned.
    The other band members obviously didn’t think it was important, since they didn’t really go try to break up the “fight” or anything of the like.

    Comment by Anonymous | June 17, 2008 | Reply

  58. this was all a long time as people are saying and when i first saw it, it actually kind of hurt because they have been preaching to us to love one another. but again they are only human and fights happen, however they should have conducted it other than on stage, it is completely the wrong example to be setting.
    but they seem all ok and happy and the break they are having should really help and like people have said they’re married and awy from their family it must be really hard so of course they will have off days. i just think they could have conducted it better.
    and i know a lot of you will disagree but the only person in that band i now have time for is frank. me and my mate went to a show, and it was the gig before he flew back home because some family member was sick or something. we waited a long time, and my friend was ill so we decided to go back to the hotel bout an hour or so after that, frank came out, he was the only one out of the five huys in that band even though he was worried about his family.
    whenever they do shows where they choose the music videos or whatever else it always frank who does it. i respect him enormously.
    and yeah i do think gee has changed since he has been with msi more i think he’s gone a little wierd, but i also see him at his happiest now. and yeah i’ve heard the rumours bout lynz n her drugs and i was concerned bout gerard getting back into it but i dont believe he is stupid enough to go through the bad times again. especially not for a girl. and if he ever did, it would be his own fault, he is a grown man, you cant blame lynz for everything.
    and in fairness if you knew them before the band or if you werent in to that sort of thing its hardly nice watching your boyfriend make out with the oppisite sex to you. and if lynz asked gerard not to i think its sweet that she is important enough to him to stop
    personally i dont think you can beat a bit of frerard. and its a shame they had their little cat fight in front of fns but it is sorted and he is still happily married. as is frank.
    so all the best to them. that is all.

    Comment by tatty | June 26, 2008 | Reply

  59. Some of you are embarrasing “MCR fans”. I love how most of you were saying “poor Frankie” when he’s the one that jumped on Gerard in the first place. He wouldn’t let go of Gerard and that’s why Gerard had to shove him. Sometimes Iero gets a little too violent for Gerard, Ray, Bob, and Mikey and he creates situations like at that Projekt Revolution show. Gerard was mad Iero got that violent hence why he kicked his amp over after the song ended. Their relationship is fine.

    Comment by Nicole | July 2, 2008 | Reply

  60. I saw a interview on youtube recently and frank and gerard were being interviewed together. they brought up the fact that back in the bullets and revenge days, they used to tackle each other on stage. Frank tackles gerard in the Famous Last Words music video. probably frank was having a little fun and gerard pushed him harder than he thought he would.

    Comment by Blake | July 9, 2008 | Reply

  61. Well, that was upsetting. :(

    Poor Frank tumbling backwards like that… it’s a shame, there hasn’t really been many Frerard moments since Gee and Lyn-Z tied the knot. I don’t know if Gee’s truly changing but I seriously hope that he and Frank don’t get into more conflicts in the future.

    Comment by Melinda | July 10, 2008 | Reply

  62. does anyone think it was just something they did?
    purposely?

    Comment by Zoeee | July 23, 2008 | Reply

  63. i see this video and it just makes me wanna cry.
    people are probably gonna give me shit for what i’m gonna say but i dont care.

    mcr saved my life. they used to be the sweetest most caring and talented band in the wurld, they really cared about their fans and wanted to help people.

    Mindless self indulgence are a bunch of talentless, homophobic, sexist, dumb, meaning less wasters who think the own the planet… they never wanted to save anyones life, i mean their lyrics are exactly surportive..

    ”you stupid motherfucker… should i talk slower like your a retard”

    ”faggott. faggott. faggot”

    ”bitches love me …”

    yeah that makes me feel really valued.

    MCR have always been so against homophobia and devalueing women then they go and get involved with a band like this.

    i don’t hate lyn-z because she married gerard – i’m a guy.

    i hate her coz she’s a twat.

    and she has changed him.

    MSI have openly said that to them music is a job.
    i mean wtf?
    they don’t deserve to be famous and they treat their fans like shit.

    i just want the old gee back :’/

    feel free to hate me for anything i’ve just said to be honest i don’t care anymore.

    Comment by dave | August 8, 2008 | Reply

  64. Mmmm
    My personal idea?
    Frank was messing and when he fellon gee it winded gee casuing him not being able to sing. Because he wanted to finish the song gerard pushed him away put being in the moment just a bit to hard causing frank to fall. Gerard being confused just got a rush of anger for pushing frank and not being able to finish his song. And this hole lyn-z thing…I dunno its really not any1 bissuness and i do like her music with Msi put i think gerards just getting a bit ruff at the edges.Getting thinner? Yea he is mabey its the stress or touring? No gerard/frank moments? Mabey lyn-zs getting a bit touchy? im not sure but i dont think gerards back to the drink… thats all i can say.

    Comment by Claire | August 17, 2008 | Reply

  65. Sorry, I know there’s no point commenting years on but I’m going to anyway. Famous Last Words’ dedication would have been for Mikey, it’s been said in interviews (including one in Blender) that the song was about Mikey and the band. But it was written while Mikey was away from Paramour. Blender described it as Gerard walking down in his bathrobe one night and

    Comment by Penelope | February 5, 2009 | Reply

  66. Sorry, I know there’s no point commenting years on but I’m going to anyway. Famous Last Words’ dedication would have been for Mikey, it’s been said in interviews (including one in Blender) that the song was about Mikey and the band. But it was written while Mikey was away from Paramour. Blender described it as Gerard walking down in his bathrobe one night and seeing Ray playing some music entitled “The Saddest Music In The World,” (it was without a refrain) and eventually Gerard started singing and summed up his feelings in the chorus. “I am not afraid to keep on living / I am not afraid to walk this world alone / Honey if you stay I’ll be forgiven / Nothing you can say can stop me going home.”

    I’ve heard (also in interviews) that Frank has said it was simply him getting a bit too violent on stage and being reminded about what not to do. This struck me as really odd however. Normally you wouldn’t answer a question with a comment that created even more questions.

    I definitely don’t think it was drug/alcohol related. If you compare Gerard’s performance during this incident to back when he was often drunk on the stage it’s still very different. better enunciation, coordination etc. I don’t think he’s drunk at all.

    We all know Frank does tend to go insane on stage, it’s a given by now. Maybe they’d argued earlier today, maybe they were tired, maybe Gerard really was sending clear “back-of” signals. Maybe we’ll never know.

    But the whole “Frerard” thing stopping? I think that’s just a sign of the band changing yet again. They spend certain periods sending certain messages. And maybe now they’re settling down with women they feel it’s no longer appropriate. But that’s their call to make.

    At the end of it, it doesn’t really seem to have affected the band. I don’t think it’s fair to go all “hate” on certain people because of it though.

    Comment by Penelope | February 5, 2009 | Reply

  67. Oh, and sorry for the double 9now triple) comment. I accidentally hit the post button too early.

    Comment by Penelope | February 5, 2009 | Reply

  68. Yea, I think Gee’s changes since he married lyn-z, (man, i hate that girl) but i still luv u Gee… n i luv u too Frank…

    Comment by FreRard_Luver-LynZ_H8er | February 25, 2009 | Reply

  69. Yea, i think Gee has been changed since he married lyn-z (man, i hate that girl) but i still luv u Gee… n i luv u too Frank…

    Comment by FreRard_Luver-LynZ_H8er | February 25, 2009 | Reply

  70. In the making of the ‘Famous Last Words’ video, there was a clip of Frank pouncing on Gerard, and Gerard described it as the way they used to play on stage when the band was younger.
    I think possibly Gerard just wasn’t in the mood for fooling around that night.
    Obviously this didn’t damage their friendship, so there isn’t much use analyzing it.
    We all have one of those days.

    xo.

    Comment by Victoria | March 8, 2009 | Reply

  71. It’s been a while since this happened, but I just have to say: This is some messed up doodoo.

    First of all: If Gerard found out a lot of his fans thought he wasn’t strong enough to stay sober, how would that make him feel? Seriously, he can do it, has been staying sober for years, and I don’t think Lyn-z would be able to influence him into it, and if she truly loves him she wouldn’t try.
    Secondly: It doesn’t seem like Frankie is really being “violent.” It’s actually more like affectionate, for him. It’s not like he attacked Gerard, and he didn’t really jump on him, more like… fell onto him. xD But not accidentally, does that make sense? Anyway, Frankie should calm down once in a while, but that’s not an excuse for pushing him like that. It didn’t seem like it was staged, Gee looked really angry and it is sad for Frankie, but everyone has bad days. And you people can’t tell me you’ve never taken it out on a friend. This shouldn’t really make you think any less of either of them in the long run.

    And you know, if I’m saying I don’t dislike Gerard because of this, it actually means something because I am in love with Frankie. =P Seriously though, Gee shouldn’t have pushed him so hard, but everybody breaks down sometimes, and if Frankie can forgive him then y’all should be able to as well.

    Love them both! <3 And Mikey, Ray, and Bob!

    Comment by JessicaIero | March 10, 2009 | Reply

  72. Hiya :) Who is Matt? Was he there to take Mikey’s place? Well anyway, Maybe G and Frankie had a small arguement, just b4 goin on stage! Maybe they didn’t ave enuff time 2 talk it out b4 gettin on stage! Wat if it woz an actual Frerard moment, where Frank woz wantin 2 do sum kissin or sumthin, yet G thawt “Not here, not rite now!” and pushed him away, 4 that reason alone? :p Well we can dream. :p Ah wotever the reason, i hope they sort it out!! Much luv xoxox <3

    Comment by Black.Parade.Girl | March 23, 2009 | Reply

  73. It’s awful 2 c them both fightin! Their quite close friends aswell :o Hmmm….wish i knew wot it woz over! The only clue i get of Gerard’s feelin’s, is wen i woz on ‘Imnotokay.net’. A guy under the name Mayonnaise, writes a very heartfelt, crude, poetic “letter” 2 a so-called other person. Ppl think this Mayonnaise person is Gerard Way, but idk. Judge 4 urself. :) Mwahz.

    Comment by PunkGurl | March 23, 2009 | Reply

  74. To comment #72:

    Matt was Mikey’s fill in for the period when Mikey took time off from the band. He was an amazing replacement, honestly.

    <3

    Comment by Victoria | March 23, 2009 | Reply

  75. I reckon gee got a bit out of control and mad because it was on live broadcast, and he didn’t expect it to happen. he even dropped his microphone which stopped him from singing and so maybe he found it a bit embarrassing. That’s just my point of view. And maybe they had finished their ‘frerard’ routines for a while. If they had been doing it more then they should be doing, while gee had a gf and frank was engaged, then people would really think that something was going on between the two, and possibly gerard didnt want people to think that.

    Comment by Frerard Supporter | April 17, 2009 | Reply

  76. he’s married 2 lyn-z and they had their 1st child bandit lee way!!!!(just incase u ppl didnt kno)

    Comment by jess | June 1, 2009 | Reply

  77. Dude, EVERYONE knows about that. It’s old news.

    Comment by Victoria | June 1, 2009 | Reply

  78. All I can say is even if it happened a long time ago and I’m sure they’re back to normal, I still don’t like seeing them like that. It’s horrible seeing them fight or anything. But I really think that Gee might have just been having a bad day and was stressed out or something. It’s happened to me before where just the little things make you snap. And that might be what happened to him.

    Comment by Danet | July 6, 2009 | Reply

  79. And also, if this was during the time when Mikey was taking a break, maybe that had something to do with it. I mean, I’m sure they were all happy that Mikey was taking some time off, but maybe Gerard just down right missed his little brother and that stressed him out some more.

    Comment by Danet | July 6, 2009 | Reply

  80. WoW!
    Can you get a clearer version???
    That definetly doesnt look staged seemed as though Matt tries to back away…
    Its all sorted though we miss Frerard!

    Comment by I miss Frerard! | March 7, 2010 | Reply


Leave a comment